Technology
at a Nanoscale:
The
Potential Uses of Nanotechnology in Medicine
Zumana
Miyfa
ENG
21003, Section C
Professor
Nargiza Matyakubova
May 9, 2014
Abstract
A modern,
new field of science with various applicable medical innovations has emerged
over the years. This revolutionary field is known as nanotechnology research.
Nanoscience involves the use of nanoparticles to develop cellular abnormality
detection mechanisms, more precise medicine, and better treatment options for
various illnesses. However, this field of research is also hindered by ethical
dilemma that arises with an issue concerning human nature. Opponents of nanomedical
research claim that nanotechnology would reduce human beings to machines and
dehumanize them while scientists take the power of science too far. In
contrast, what is overlooked is that numerous human beings would benefit from
the medical uses of nanotechnology. For example, nanoscience research can help
detect malignant diseases, such as Alzheimer’s and even cancer, through early
detection. Nanotechnology can also be utilized to reduce medical costs by mass
producing artificial limbs are a quick rate in order to supply them for
patients who require amputations. These nanomedical advances and much more are
the reasons why nanoscience research should be invested in rather than deterred
by ethical debate.
Technology
at a Nanoscale:
The
Potential Uses of Nanotechnology in Medicine
What if the answer to effectively treating
critical diseases lies in the innovations of technology? Science and technology
combined is getting closer to finding better treatments and cures for
detrimental illnesses, such as cancer. Nanoscience and nanotechnology involve
the concept of visualizing and controlling individual atoms and molecules on a
nanoscale; one inch is 25,400,000 nanometers (Hughes, 2014, p. 1). The nanoscale is so small that individual
nanoparticles cannot be seen with the naked eye. Therefore, the scanning
tunneling microscope and the atomic force microscope, which allow
nanoscale particles to be seen by the human eye, were pivotal technological
innovations that sparked “the age of nanotechnology” (Love, Estroff, Kriebel, Nuzzo, & Whitesides, 2004, p. 1114).
Nanotechnology is a modern and revolutionary type of technology that breaks
down everything into miniscule particles that could be applied to various
sciences, such as chemistry, biology, physics, and engineering. It is already
used to test and manufacture certain cosmetics and sunscreens, but further research
is necessary to utilize nanotechnology to create better drugs and treatments
for illnesses, such as cancer (Ferrari,
2005, p. 1). However, some argue that nanotechnology is unethical
because it dehumanizes human beings with the use of nanobots and technology
surpasses the power of human will. Although there is an ethical debate in the
scientific community about nanotechnology, undermining the laws of nature,
nanotechnology research can potentially change the world of medicine and
improve the lives of numerous individuals who deal with life-threatening
diseases.
Current Breakthroughs
of Nanoscience Research
Nanotechnology has already had a positive
impact on ill-ridden human beings with the development of “nanomedicine” and
“smart drugs,” which can help treat diseases while reducing side effects.
According to Goldman, L. and Coussens, C. (2005), “The National Institutes of
Health defines nanomedicine as the integration between nanotechnology and nanoscience.
NIH is planning to support research on biological systems and molecules such as
proteins, DNA, and RNA and how these molecules interact with each other” (p.
3). Nanomedicine has the potential to change the entire field of medicine
because smart drugs are tiny enough to deliver medicine into patients who have
high blood pressure very precisely. These drugs could also be used to treat a plethora
of diseases, but further research is necessary for such progress to take place. Smart drugs work by building “biohybrid
systems or even biomimetic materials (mimicking biological recognition) for
drug delivery, drug targeting, and tissue engineering devices” (Peppas, Hilt,
& Thomas, 2007, p. 1). The reason that nanomedicine and smart drugs would be
beneficial is that they would target specific cells with precision since they are
so miniature. Therefore, the new innovative drugs would not have an adverse
effect on healthy cells (Whitman, 2013, p. 1). This breakthrough is one of the
foundations that nanotechnology research is setting for the future because
medicine is not meant to cause more harm than good.
Another revolutionary breakthrough in
nanotechnology research is the application of three-dimensional printing to
nanomedical studies in order to print artificial body parts and reduce medical
costs by keeping up with patient demands. Nanotechnology combined with
three-dimensional printing can help “[build] artificial limbs for amputee
victims is a long and expensive process. With advanced 3D printing, a
prosthetic limb could go from design to finished product for a fraction of the
price (and all under one roof), cutting down on waste and time in the process”
(Richter, 2013, p. 1). Three-dimensional printing could mass-produce the
necessary nanoparticle and prosthetic body parts at a remarkable speed as well
as being cost effective. More individuals would be able to receive the care
that they need regardless of the expenses, so the government should consider
investing in nanotechnology research. Both three-dimensional printing and
nanotechnology research have been controversial developments due to ethical issues,
but the benefits can help even those who cannot afford the best medical care.
In addition, nanowires can significantly
assist patients who are risk of high blood pressure by monitoring their blood
pressures on a long-term basis. Richter, A. (2013) stated, “Popular Mechanics
reports [that] they have designed an implantable nanowire that records vital
stats and can alert the patient or doctor if fluctuations in blood pressure
become alarming. The alerts could be especially useful when patients are
traveling abroad” (p. 1). These nanowires are a series of nanoscale devices,
which the patients would not feel directly. However, they would monitor blood
flow rates and heart rates while constantly sending reports to physicians in
the case of any irregularities. When nanotechnology becomes so pervasive, ethical
issues arise because the nanowire would have to be implanted within the veins
of individuals who are at risk for high blood pressure, but doctors would able
to treat them more properly (Peppas, Hilt, & Thomas, 2007, p. 1). The use
of nanowires shows that nanotechnology research is applicable to a variety of
illnesses since high blood pressure is a fairly common disease, and the
benefits of the research outweigh any ethical dilemma.
Similarly, gold nanoparticles could be used
to detect early stages of Alzheimer’s disease, which would allow for more
efficient treatment. The way that nanotechnology helps detect Alzheimer’s
diseases is by “gold-nanoparticle-modified probes [being] used in conjunction
with microcantilevers to develop a DNA assay with single mismatch
discrimination and to transduce molecular binding into readily detectable
micrometre-scale deflections” (Ferrari, 2005, p. 166). In other words, gold
nanoparticles helped develop a DNA test that could catch a single gene that is
mismatched from the others because that discrepancy would mean that there is a
possibility for Alzheimer’s to develop in that person. According to Resnik, D.
B. and Tinkle, S. S. (2007), “Researchers have [also] developed an assay that
uses gold nanoparticles to detect proteins, DNA, and other compounds found in
biological samples” (p. 4). The test for
early detection of Alzheimer’s is being researched on and perfected by various
scientists, but so far it has the ability to accurately find abnormalities in
proteins as well as DNA. This type of scanning using gold nanoparticles can be
applied to a wider array of illnesses through more research. Alzheimer’s is a
traumatic disease that has no cure, but nanotechnology research gives those
patients hope for attempting to live more healthy lives.
Nanotechnology can also be applied to
infection containment in hospital by incorporating nanoparticles into the lab
coats and supplies that physicians use. Nanotechnology can one day prevent
infections from spreading since “microfluidic chip-based nanolabs [are] capable
of monitoring and manipulating individual cells and nanoscale probes to track
the movements of cells and individual molecules as they move about in their
environments” (Whitman, 2013, p. 1). If these nanolabs were to be introduced to
hospitals, they would help physicians keep track of where infectious cells and
germs are traveling. Therefore, it would be easier to create specific rooms to
confine the infections to prevent them from spreading to other patients and
staff. Researchers in Europe are also using nanotechnology in order to develop
protective hospital garments that “will work by releasing antibiotics from
nanocapsules triggered by the presence of disease-causing pathogenic bacteria,
which will target treatment before the infection takes hold” (Love, Estroff, Kriebel, Nuzzo, &
Whitesides, 2004, p. 1120). The nanocapsule lined lab coats and gloves
are a work in progress, but they can potentially release antibiotics that would
kill the germs even if they were air-borne, so hospitals would become an even
safer environment to treat patients in. It is extremely important for
physicians to remain safe and prevent deadly infections from spreading in
hospital. Since nanotechnology can be used as a safety precaution, nanoscience
research should be encouraged without being insulated from criticism.
Ethical Issues
Regarding Nanotechnology Use
Although there are many benefits to
continuing nanoscience research, the ethical controversy is that nanotechnology
dehumanizes human beings with the use of nanobots and the technology surpasses
the power of human will. According to Mnyusiwalla,
A., Daar, A. D, & Singer, P. A. (2003), “The ethical issues fall
into the areas of equity, privacy, security, environment, and metaphysical
questions concerning human–machine interactions” (p. 11). Most of these ethical
problems can be solved through regulation of nanotechnology research and usage,
but the metaphysical questions should not be an issue because humans will still
be human even if they nanoparticles implanted in their bodies. Man cannot alter
the essence of a human being, but the wondrous nanoscale devices would only
help people live healthier lives. Another issue is that during clinical trials,
experimenters expose human tissue to nano-devices and this type of exposure can
have minimal harmful effects on the test subjects (Resnik & Tinkle, 2007,
p. 1). The risks to this type of exposure to nanoparticles are so minimal that
the breakthroughs and discoveries should be weighed more heavily than the risks
of the clinical trials. However, stricter regulation of the clinical trials
should be enforced in order to minimize risks even more. Natural law asserts
that humans have the innate desire to sympathize and empathize with other
people and help them, and nanotechnology has too many overarching medical to be
hindered by ethical opponents.
Nanotechnology can also have negative
impacts on the human subjects who participate in research studies, but the
emerging discoveries from that research have potential to help society at a
larger scale. Issues in nanoscience research arise “[when] nanomedicine
experiments expose people to nanomaterials other than the [test] subjects,
these experiments could cause harm to research staff, fetuses, breast-fed
infants, or even family members” (Resnik & Tinkle, 2007, p. 13). As a
result of nanotechnology research having overwhelming social benefits, even
critics, like David B. Resnik, agree that there should be more regulation
rather than arguments in the scientific community (Resnik & Tinkle, 2007,
p. 10). Nanoparticles are dangerous to test and use because “the size, shape
and physicochemical properties of nanomaterials are very dependent on their
microenvironment and may change once they enter an organism” (Resnik &
Tinkle, 2007, p. 7). Further research is necessary to ensure that the
nanoparticles become more predictable and that would eliminate the risk of them
changing once they enter the human body. Any type of scientific research can
have detrimental effects on those who participate in clinical research, but
nanotechnology research has been conducted on mice as well as humans to ensure
the practicality of the advancements that emerge from experimentation.
Nanotechnology and
Cancer Research
For example, one major way that
nanotechnology research can benefit a greater number of people is that it
facilitates cancer research in finding a possible cure. According to Varmus, H.
(2013), “Nanotechnology offers a range of tools that can be used to monitor
individual cells and track the movements of cells—and even of individual
molecules—in their environment. Such tools will enable researchers to study,
monitor, and manipulate the multiple systems that go awry in the cancer
process” (p. 1). More cancer victims survive if the cancer is detected at an
early stage and tools made with nanoparticles would help detect which cells are
cancerous at the earliest stage possible. Therefore, nanotechnology research
helps accelerate cancer research since it “can provide rapid and sensitive
detection of cancer-related molecules, enabling scientists to detect molecular
changes even when they occur only in a small percentage of cells” (Grodzinski,
2012, p. 1). Millions of individuals are diagnosed with cancer, but
nanotechnology research is modernizing the way cancer research is approached,
the way cancer is detected, the way it is prevented, and how it can be treated
more successfully.
Nanotechnology can also help detect cancer
at its earliest stages through molecular imagining. According to Ferrari, M.
(2005), “Nanotechnology is no stranger
to oncology: liposomes are early examples of cancer nanotherapeutics, and
nanoscale-targeted magnetic resonance imaging contrast agents illustrate the
application of nanotechnology to diagnostics” (p. 162). Molecular imaging is a
type of nanoscale imaging in which nanodevices transport dye into organs and
cells that have cancer in order to pinpoint which cells have transmutations. Sensitive
nanoscale devices can help detect cancer cells on a molecular level, so even
rare abnormalities in cells can be traced before symptoms of cancer become
evident in humans (Whitman, 2013, p. 1). This type of cancer detection has already been put into use, but more
research would make nanoscale imaging more precise. Early detection of
cancerous cells can significantly increase a person’s chances of surviving;
therefore, scientists should put more effort into furthering nanotechnology research
instead of debating it.
Furthermore, one aspect of nanoscience
research is geared toward preventing cancer from returning and controlling the
harmful cell mutations by targeting and destroying malign cells. Cancer can be
hindered from returning to patients when nanotechnologists “develop devices
that indicate when [cancer cell] markers appear in the body and that deliver
agents to reverse premalignant changes or to kill those cells that have the
potential to become malignant” (Varmus, 2013, p. 1). Combining the early
detection nanoparticles that dye the cancer cells with ways to kill them
creates the most efficient way to deal with cancer. The best way to ensure that
cancer does not return is by destroying tumors from the inside, and scientists
have developed “nanoshells” that “absorb light of different frequencies,
generating heat” in order to thermally diminish cancer cells (Grodzinski, 2012,
p. 1). Nanoscale devices are so miniscule that they cannot be seen by the human
eye, but they are remarkable at pinpointing cancerous cells; these devices
should be available for all cancer treatment centers to utilize.
Moreover, nanotechnology can even make
chemotherapy more effective at treating cancer because nanoscale devices can
assist in reducing tumor sizes. According to Mnyusiwalla, A., Daar, A. D, & Singer, P. A. (2003),
“Nanoparticle research has generated products including a nanoparticle carrier
able to cross the blood–brain barrier to deliver a chemotherapeutic for the
treatment of brain tumours” (p. 9). This nanoparticle carrier is especially
revolutionary because the brain is such a complex organ that it has been
extremely difficult to treat brain tumors, but the use of nanotechnology would
make it possible to introduce chemotherapy to the brain. Introducing
nanomedicine to chemotherapy also makes the chemo treatments less detrimental
to the bodies of cancer patients since the targeted cells are easier to
differentiate from the healthy cells (Ferrari, 2005, p. 167). Therefore,
healthy cells would not be affected by the chemo and patients would experience
less side effects of chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Even though
chemotherapy can treat cancer, nanotechnology based therapeutic methods are
much safer for the body; there are so many people who need nanotechnology to
help them survive that time should not be wasted debating the ethics of
research.
Nanoscience Reducing
Medical Costs
A more recent, developing potential use for
nanotechnology is cultivating nerve cell growth in damaged spinal cord or brain
cells, and this can revolutionize the capabilities of medicine to healing human
beings as much as possible. Whitman, L. (2013) stated that “[t]here is early
work on [growing cells using nanotechnology] in the optical nerves of hamsters.
Another method is exploring use of nanofibers to regenerate damaged spinal
nerves in mice” (p. 1). This use of nanotechnology has the potential to regrow
cells in the eyes and spinal cord, which are two very delicate body parts to
work with. Further research is crucial for cell regeneration to be used in
order to treat illness. Researchers at Brown University have been conducting
experiments and came to the conclusion that infusing titanium in nanoparticles
can allow scientists to regrow and heal bones by making them stronger
(Sirivisoot, 2007, p. 1). If bones could be regenerated using nanoparticles,
arthritis could be cured and numerous individuals would live their lives
without feeling as much pain in their joints. This type of nanoscience
development may seem as if scientists are taking too much power into their own
hands, but the ultimate goal is to better the well being of all people.
Summation of Benefits Outweighing the Costs
Ultimately,
nanotechnology is advancing extremely quickly and this is just because humans
are dealing with various illnesses that do not have cures yet. Nanoscience
research has so much potential that it may lead to the cure for cancer,
Alzheimer’s, and even high blood pressure one day. Some of the key features of
nanotechnology is that nanoparticles and smart drugs infused with those
particles can deliver medicine precisely to specific organs, nanowires can
better monitor heart rate and blood pressure, nanovectors that make
chemotherapy more effective, and nanoshells can burn cancerous tumors and
prevent them from returning. Researchers also working on nanoparticle
regeneration, which can help create artificial limbs at a faster rate in order
to cut the costs of prosthetics. All of these innovations and more would
benefit the human race at large, but that does not mean that humans would turn
into robots or lose any qualities that make people human.
References
Ferrari, M. (2005). Cancer Nanotechnology: Opportunities and Challenges. Nature Publishing
Group
Review Papers. Retrieved
from
http://faculty.washington.edu/markeh/MSE599/Ferarri_Nature_cancer_nanotechn.pdf
Goldman, L. and Coussens, C.
(2005). Implications of Nanotechnology for Environmental
Health Research.
Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.
Grodzinski, P. (2012). Benefits for
Treatment and Clinical Applications. National
Cancer
Institute Alliance for Nanotechnology in
Cancer Publications. Retrieved from http://nano.cancer.gov/learn/impact/treatment.asp
Mnyusiwalla, A., Daar, A. D, & Singer, P. A. (2003). ‘Mind The Gap’:
Science And Ethics In
Nanotechnology. Institute of Physics Publishing. Retrieved from
http://portal.unesco.org/shs/fr/files/6510/10951530841Mindthegap.pdf/Mindthegap.pdf
Love, J. C., Estroff, L. A., Kriebel, J. K., Nuzzo, R. G., &
Whitesides, G. M. (2004). Self-
Assembled Monolayers of Thiolates on Metals
as a Form of Nanotechnology. Harvard
University Chemical Reviews Publications. Retrieved from
ftp://c-50-131-223-47.hsd1.ca.comcast.net/shares/USB_Storage/2011_Work/
BusinessDev/2011-06%20Nano%20Glucose%20Sensor/2005_Self-Assembled
MonolayersThiolates_Love_Whitesides.pdf
Peppas, N. A., Hilt, J. Z., &
Thomas, J. B. (2007). Nanotechnology in Therapeutics: Current
Technology
and Applications. Norfolk, UK: Horizon Bioscience Publication.
Resnik, D. B. and Tinkle, S. S.
(2007). Ethical Issues in Clinical Trials Involving Nanomedicine.
Contemporary Clincal Trials Publications. Retrieved
from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2695593/
Richter, A. (2013). The Future of
Nanotechnology: Four Ways Nanotechnology Will
Revolutionize
Medicine. Nanotechnology Now
Publications. Retrieved from
http://www.nanotech-now.com/columns/?article=778
Sirivisoot, S. (2007). Greater Osteoblast Functions on Multiwalled
Carbon Nanotubes Grown
from Anodized Nanotubular Titanium for
Orthopedic Applications. IOP Science
Journal Publications. Retrieved from
http://iopscience.iop.org/0957-4484/18/36/365102
Varmus, H. (2013). Cancer
Snapshots: Disease Focused and Other Snapshots. National Cancer
Institutes Publications. Retrieved from
http://www.cancer.gov/researchandfunding/snapshots/nanotechnology
Whitman, L. (2013). Benefits and
Applications. National Nanotechnology
Initiative
Publications. Retrieved from
http://www.nano.gov/you/nanotechnology-benefits
No comments:
Post a Comment