Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Annotated Bibliography






Technology at a Nanoscale:
The Potential Uses of Nanotechnology in Medicine
Annotated Bibliography

Zumana Miyfa
ENG 21003, Section C
Professor Nargiza Matyakubova
April 12, 2014







Ferrari, M. (2005). Cancer Nanotechnology: Opportunities and Challenges. Nature Publishing
Group Review Papers. Retrieved from
http://www.faculty.washington.edu/markeh/MSE599/Ferrari_Nature_cancer_nanotechn.pdf
Ferrari’s review paper is an in-depth analysis of how effectively nanoscale devices help fight cancer. The main devices he mentions are nanowires that can detect cancerous cells at an early stage, nanovectors that make chemotherapy more effective, and nanoshells that are capable of burning malignant cells to prevent cancer from returning. These devices are too miniscule to be seen by the human eye, but they are very precise when treating cancer. Ferrari (2005) also makes the point that there should be further investment in the field of nanotechnology research in order to further cancer research. His detailed review paper provides sufficient evidence to show that nanotechnology has various uses in medicine and can help a greater number of people. Although Ferrari does not address the ethical debate that arises in the conversation about nanoscience, he provides detailed information about the challenges that scientists face when utilizing nanotechnology and the developments that numerous researchers have discovered thus far. These achievements in cancer nanotechnology research lay the foundations for future studies, which require investment and support from opponents as well.  
Mnyusiwalla, A., Daar, A. D., & Singer, P. A. (2003). “Mind the Gap:” Science and Ethics in
Nanotechnology. Institute of Physics Publishing. Retrieved from
http://portal.unesco.org/shs/es/files/6510/10951530841Mindthegap.pdf/Mindthegap.pdf
In this article, three researchers, Mnyusiwalla, Daar, and Singer (2003), take a look at nanotechnology from ethical, legal, and social perspectives. They make the claim that nanoscience research is progressing at a far more rapid rate than the ethics regarding the implications of nanotechnology. The statistical data included in the article shows that investment in nanotechnology research has increased at a dramatic rate from 1997 to 2002, and more publications have been made regarding the achievements of nanoscience technology. However, the main concern is that the public is not informed about the ethical implications of implanting nanoparticles into humans, which would make people more “machine-like.” Even though this article is data-driven and provides evidence that there is an ethical dilemma surrounding nanotechnology, the authors fail to take the benefits of nanoscience research into consideration. If the positive effects of nanotechnology were to be included, they would outweigh the ethical argument that opponents make against nanoscience research since one of the main objectives of developing nano-devices is to treat incurable illnesses, such as Alzheimer’s and cancer. 
Resnik, D. B. and Tinkle, S. S. (2007). Ethical Issues in Clinical Trials Involving Nanomedicine.
Contemporary Clincal Trials Publications. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2695593/
This research paper by Resnik and Tinkle is about the ethical dilemma that surrounds the clinical trials that nanotechnology research requires in order for scientists to learn more about nanoparticles. There is danger in testing and utilizing nanoparticles because they may change once they enter organisms since they are extremely dependent on their surroundings. The two main types of nanomedicine clinical trials that are being conducted to this day are diagnostic tests for early detection of cellular illnesses and those that test drug delivery devices. According to Resnik and Tinkle (2007), testing the drug delivery nano-devices can harm the test subjects if the targeted cells are not malignant to begin with. Therefore, even though nanotechnology can have beneficial effects on numerous people, individuals who participate in clinical trials may face major health risks. The ethical argument presented in this research paper adequately shows that ethics should be considered in the realm of nanotechnology research. Resnik and Tinkle avoid bias in this paper by including the counterargument that nanoscience offers a tremendous amount of innovations in the field of medicine, and they agree that clinical trials should be regulated more strictly rather than allowing ethical debate to hinder making new discoveries. Overall, this source provides an alternative view on nanotechnology by showing the positive effects as well as the negative effects that nanoscience can have, and it is important to consider both sides when choosing a position on such a controversial research issue.  
Richter, A. (2013). The Future of Nanotechnology: Four Ways Nanotechnology Will Revolutionize
Medicine. Nanotechnology Now Publications. Retrieved from
http://www.nanotech-now.com/columns/?article=778

Richter’s article summarizes four revolutionary ways that nanotechnology can potentially change the field of medicine. When nanotechnology is incorporated with three-dimensional printing, artificial limbs can be produced at a faster rate and the costs for medical supplies could be reduced sharply. Another benefit that Richter (2013) mentions is that nanomedicine can make drugs target cancerous cells more precisely and treat tumors without causing as many side effects as chemotherapy. Nanoparticles also play an important role in the detection of certain diseases, like cancer and Alzheimer’s. These microscopic particles are capable of providing surgeons with better images of tumors when mixed with dye since they are small enough to color each individual cell. The information in this source effectively supports the claim that nanotechnology has overwhelmingly progressive effects on society as a whole. Although Richter does not address any of the drawbacks of nanoscience research in the article, she focuses on primarily on the advances that nanotechnology is underway of making. These nanomedicine developments seem to be too radical to exist, but they are the ones that truly exemplify the future of medicine. Therefore, the groundbreaking discoveries that scientists have yet to put into practice have enough potential to take precedence over any ethical debate that stands in the way of nanotechnology.

No comments:

Post a Comment