Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Thesis and Detailed Outline for Final Research Paper









Technology at a Nanoscale:
The Potential Uses of Nanotechnology in Medicine

Thesis and Detailed Outline

Zumana Miyfa
ENG 21003, Section C
Professor Nargiza Matyakubova
April 4, 2014









Title - Technology at a Nanoscale: The Potential Uses of Nanotechnology in Medicine
Thesis - Although there is an ethical debate in the scientific community about nanotechnology
going against the laws of nature, nanotechnology research can potentially change the   
world of medicine and improve the lives of numerous individuals who have to deal with
life-threatening diseases.
Body Paragraph #1 -
Topic sentence: One breakthrough in nanoscience research is the development of
“nanomedicine” and “smart drugs,” which can help treat diseases while reducing side effects.  
Supporting Details:
  • According to Goldman, L. and Coussens, C. (2005), “The National Institutes of Health defines nanomedicine as the integration between nanotechnology and nanosience. NIH is planning to support research on biological systems and molecules such as proteins, DNA, and RNA and how these molecules interact with each other” (p. 3).
  • “Biomimetic methods are now used to build biohybrid systems or even biomimetic materials (mimicking biological recognition) for drug delivery, drug targeting, and tissue engineering devices,” which are also known as smart drugs (Peppas, N., 2006, p. 1). 
  • The reason that nanomedicine and smart drugs would benefit a great number of people is that the drugs would target specific cells efficiently since they would be so miniature. Therefore, the new innovative drugs would not have an adverse effect on healthy cells (Whitman, 2013, p. 1).
Clincher: This breakthrough is one of the foundations that nanotechnology research is setting for
   the future because medicine should not cause more harm than good.
Body Paragraph #2 -
Topic sentence: Another revolutionary breakthrough in nanotechnology research is applying
three-dimensional printing with nanoscience in order to print artificial body parts
  and reduce medical costs.
Supporting Details:
  • Nanotechnology combined with three-dimensional printing can help “[build] artificial limbs for amputee victims is a long and expensive process. With advanced 3D printing, a prosthetic limb could go from design to finished product for a fraction of the price (and all under one roof), cutting down on waste and time in the process” (Richter, 2013, p. 1).
  • Three-dimensional printing can mass-produce the necessary nanoparticle and prosthetic body parts at a remarkable speed as well as being cost effective (Richter, 2013, p. 2).
  • More individuals would be able to receive the care that they need regardless of the expenses, so the government should invest in nanotechnology research (Richter, 2013, p. 2).
Clincher: Both three-dimensional printing and nanotechnology research have been controversial
   developments due to ethical reasons, but the benefits can help even those who cannot
   afford the best medical care.
Body Paragraph #3 -
Topic sentence: In addition, nanowires can significantly assist patients who are risk of high
  blood pressure by monitoring their blood pressures on a long-term basis.
Supporting Details:
  • Richter, A. (2013) stated, “Popular Mechanics reports they've designed an implantable nanowire that records vital stats and can alert the patient or doctor if fluctuations in blood pressure become alarming. The alerts could be especially useful when patients are traveling abroad” (p. 1).
  • Ethical issues arise because the nanowire would have to be implanted within the veins of individuals who are at risk for high blood pressure, but doctors would able to treat them more properly (Peppas, 2006, p. 1).
Clincher: The use of nanowires shows that nanotechnology research is applicable to various
   illnesses since high blood pressure is a fairly common disease, and the benefits of the
   research outweigh any ethical dilemma.
Body Paragraph #4 -
Topic sentence: Similarly, gold nanoparticles can be used to detect early stages of Alzheimer’s
  disease; therefore, the illness can be treated more effectively after detection.
Supporting Details:
  • The way that nanotechnology helps detect Alzheimer’s diseases is by “gold-nanoparticle-modified probes [being] used in conjuction with microcantilevers to develop a DNA assay with single mismatch discrimination and to transduce molecular binding into readily detectable micrometre-scale deflections” (Ferrari, 2005, p. 166).
  • According to Resnik, D. B. and Tinkle, S. S. (2007), “Researchers have developed an assay that uses gold nanoparticles to detect proteins, DNA, and other compounds found in biological samples” (p. 4).
Clincher: Alzheimer’s is a traumatic disease that has no cure, but nanotechnology research gives
   those patients hope for attempting to live more healthy lives.
Body Paragraph #5 -
Topic sentence: Nanotechnology can also be applied to infection containment in hospital by
  incorporating nanoparticles into the lab coats and supplies that physicians use.
Supporting Details:
  • Nanotechnology can one day prevent infections from spreading since “microfluidic chip-based nanolabs [are] capable of monitoring and manipulating individual cells and nanoscale probes to track the movements of cells and individual molecules as they move about in their environments” (Whitman, 2013, p. 1).
  • Researchers in Europe are also using nanotechnology in order to develop protective hospital garments that “will work by releasing antibiotics from nanocapsules triggered by the presence of disease-causing pathogenic bacteria, which will target treatment before the infection takes hold” (Hogan, 2014, p. 1)
Clincher: It is extremely important for physicians to remain safe and prevent deadly infections
   from spreading in hospital, and since nanotechnology can be used as a safety
   precaution, nanoscience research should be encouraged rather than criticized.
Body Paragraph #6 -
Topic sentence: Although there are many benefits to continuing nanoscience research, the ethical
controversy is that nanotechnology dehumanizes human beings with the use of  nanobots and the technology surpasses the power of human will.
Supporting Details:
·      According to Mnyusiwalla, A., Daar, A. D, & Singer, P. A. (2003), “The ethical issues fall into the areas of equity, privacy, security, environment, and metaphysical questions concerning human–machine interactions” (p. 11).
·      During clinical trials, experimenters expose human tissue to nano-devices and this type of exposure can have minimal harmful effects on the test subjects (Resnik, D. B. and Tinkle, S. S., 2007, p. 1). Therefore, stricter regulation of the clinical trials should be enforced.
Clincher: Natural law asserts that humans have the innate desire to sympathize and empathize
with other people and help them, and nanotechnology has too many overarching    
medical to be hindered by ethical opponents.
Body Paragraph #7 -
Topic sentence: Nanotechnology can also have negative impacts on the human subjects who
participate in research studies, but the emerging discoveries from that research have potential to help society at a larger scale.
Supporting Details:
  • Issues in nanoscience research arise “[when] nanomedicine experiments expose people to nanomaterials other than the [test] subjects, these experiments could cause harm to research staff, fetuses, breast-fed infants, or even family members” (Resnik, D. B. & Tinkle, S. S., 2007, p. 13).
  • As a result of nanotechnology research having overwhelming social benefits, even critics, like David B. Resnik, agree that there should be more regulation rather than arguments in the scientific community (Resnik, D. B. & Tinkle, S. S., 2007, p. 10).
  • Nanoparticles are dangerous to test and use because “the size, shape and physicochemical properties of nanomaterials are very dependent on their microenvironment and may change once they enter an organism” (Resnik, D. B. & Tinkle, S. S., 2007, p. 7).
Clincher: Any type of scientific research can have detrimental effects on those who participate in
    clinical research, but nanotechnology research has been conducted on mice as well as
   humans to ensure the practicality of the advancements that emerge from 
   experimentation.
Body Paragraph #8 -
Topic sentence: For example, one major way that nanotechnology research can benefit a greater
  number of people is that it facilitates cancer research in finding a possible cure.
Supporting Details:
  • According to Varmus, H (2013), “Nanotechnology offers a range of tools that can be used to monitor individual cells and track the movements of cells—and even of individual molecules—in their environment. Such tools will enable researchers to study, monitor, and manipulate the multiple systems that go awry in the cancer process” (p. 1).
  • Nanotecnhology research helps accelerate cancer research since it “can provide rapid and sensitive detection of cancer-related molecules, enabling scientists to detect molecular changes even when they occur only in a small percentage of cells” (Grodzinski, 2012, p. 1).
Clincher: Millions of individuals are diagnosed with cancer, but nanotechnology research is
   modernizing the way cancer research is approached, the way cancer is detected, the
   way it is prevented, and how it can be treated more successfully.
Body Paragraph #9 -
Topic sentence: Nanotechnology can also help detect cancer at its earliest stages through
  molecular imagining.
Supporting Details:
  • According to Ferrari, M. (2005), “Nanotechnology is no stranger to oncology: liposomes are early examples of cancer nanotherapeutics, and nanoscale-targeted magnetic resonance imaging contrast agents illustrate the application of nanotechnology to diagnostics” (p. 162). 
  • Sensitive nanoscale devices can help detect cancer cells on a molecular level, so even rare abnormalities in cells can be traced before symptoms of cancer become evident in humans (Whitman, 2013, p. 1).
Clincher: Early detection of cancerous cells can significantly increase a person’s chances of
   surviving; therefore, scientists should put more effort into furthering nanotechnology  
   research instead of debating it.
Body Paragraph #10 -
Topic sentence: Furthermore, one aspect of nanoscience research is geared toward preventing
cancer from returning and controlling the harmful cell mutations by targeting and destroying malign cells.


Supporting Details:
  • Cancer can be hindered from returning to patients when nanotechnologists “develop devices that indicate when [cancer cell] markers appear in the body and that deliver agents to reverse premalignant changes or to kill those cells that have the potential to become malignant” (Varmus, 2013, p. 1).
  • The best way to ensure that cancer does not return is by destroying tumors from the inside, and scientists have developed “nanoshells” that “absorb light of different frequencies, generating heat” in order to thermally diminish cancer cells (Grodzinski, 2012, p. 1).
Clincher: Nanoscale devices are so miniscule that they cannot be seen by the human eye, but
   they are remarkable at pinpointing cancerous cells; these devices should be available
   for all cancer treatment centers to utilize.
Body Paragraph #11 -
Topic sentence: Moreover, nanotechnology can even make chemotherapy more effective at
  treating cancer because nanoscale devices can assist in reducing tumor sizes.
Supporting Details:
·      According to Mnyusiwalla, A., Daar, A. D, & Singer, P. A. (2003), “Nanoparticle research has generated products including a nanoparticle carrier able to cross the blood–brain barrier to deliver a chemotherapeutic for the treatment of brain tumours” (p. 9).
·      As stated by Ferrari (2005), “The use of molecularly targeted nanovectors affords at least four potential advantages over conventional antibody-guided therapy: the delivery of much greater therapeutic payloads per target biorecognition event; the ability to carry multiple, potentially different targeting agents, providing selectivity enhancement98; the ability to integrate means to bypass biological barriers; and the colocalized delivery of multiple agents, resulting in targeted combination therapy” (p. 166).
  • The results of experiments that show the positive effects that introducing nanomedicine to chemotherapy shows that the chemo treatments are not as detrimental to the bodies of cancer patients since the targeted cells are easier to differentiate (Ferrari, 2005, p. 167).
Clincher: Even though chemotherapy can treat cancer, nanotechnology based therapeutic
   methods are much safer for the body; there are so many people who need
   nanotechnology to help them survive that time should not be wasted debating the ethics
   of research.
Body Paragraph #12 -
Topic sentence: A more recent, developing potential use for nanotechnology is cultivating nerve
cell growth in damaged spinal cord or brain cells, and this can revolutionize the 
capabilities of medicine to healing human beings as much as possible.
Supporting Details:
  • Whitman, L. (2013) stated that “[t]here is early work on [growing cells using nanotechnology] in the optical nerves of hamsters. Another method is exploring use of nanofibers to regenerate damaged spinal nerves in mice” (p. 1).
  • Researchers at Brown University have been conducting experiments and came to the conclusion that infusing titanium in nanoparticles can allow scientists to regrow and heal bones by making them stronger (Sirivisoot, 2007, p. 1)
Clincher: This nanoscience development may seem as if scientists are taking too much power

   into their own hands, but the ultimate goal is to better the well-being of all people. 

No comments:

Post a Comment