Zumana Miyfa
ENG 21003, Section C
April 2, 2014
In-Class Writing
The
Trauma of Partnership Disagreement
Brief
Introduction: In Solomon E. Asch’s experiment, regarding
conformity, a subject was forced to make decisions on his own when his partner
was opposing his correct answers to join the majority and then completely
removed from the room.
Thesis: The
loss of support ultimately failed to strengthen the subject’s independence and
had a negative impact on his ability to withstand conforming to the majority’s
incorrect answers.
Body
Paragraph 1
Topic
sentence: When the partner and subject disagreed about the answers to
the experiment’s question, the subject was more inclined to joining the
majority if his partner did so as well.
Supporting
Details
·
According to Asch’s experiment, “The instructed partner began by
answering correctly on the first six trials. With his support the subject
usually resisted pressure from the majority: 18 of 27 subjects were completely
independent. But after six trials the partner joined the majority. As soon as
he did so, there was an abrupt rise in the subjects’ errors” (Asch, 1955, p.
5).
Clincher: A
partner can only influence a person to be independent if the two are in
agreement with each other, but if disagreement arises, people are more likely
to blindly follow the majority in order to fit in with society.
Body
Paragraph 2
Topic
sentence: After the partner was asked to leave the room, the subject
was unable to resist conforming to the majority’s answers even though he knew
he had the correct answers to begin with.
Supporting
Details:
·
When the partner of the experiment was told to
leave the room, “the majority [was] unanimously giving correct answers. Then
they gradually broke away until on the sixth trial the naive subject was alone
and the group unanimously against him. As
long as the subject had anyone on his side, he was almost invariably independent, but as soon as he found himself
alone, the tendency to conform to the majority rose abruptly” (Asch, 1955, p.
5).
·
In another experiment, Stanley Milgram’s
experiment on obedience, subjects were told to deliver shocks to other
participants who could not answer trivial questions correctly after memorizing
lists of words. Individuals were actually obedient and delivered increasing
amounts of electric shock to people who could not answer questions correctly.
This experiment shows that humans are inherently obedient even when others are
harmed and that creates a dangerous combination with following the majority
blindly because the majority may instruct individuals to obey unjust rules.
Clincher: A
person tends to be even less independent without the assistance of support from
a partner; this lack of independence can have an adverse effect on society if
people simply suppress their critical thinking skills in order to fit in.
Body
Paragraph 3
Topic
sentence: A person’s resistance to conforming to the majority depends
on how wrong the majority is rather than how large the majority group is, and
having a partner does not necessarily motivate someone to embrace their
independent opinions.
Supporting
Details:
·
One main conclusion of the experiment was that
“an individual’s resistance to group pressure in these experiments depends to a considerable degree on how wrong the
majority is” (Asch, 1955, p. 5).
·
When relating this social experiment to the
bigger picture, it becomes obvious that “the tendency to conformity in our
society [is] so strong that reasonably intelligent and well-meaning young
people are willing to call white black is a matter of concern” (Asch, 1955, p.
5).
Clincher: Even
though the partner was not able to help the subject voice the correct answers,
there is hope that individuals may be able to gain the courage and dare to be
different if they are confident that they are correct.
No comments:
Post a Comment