Zumana Miyfa
ENG 21003 C
Professor Nargiza
Matyakubova
1
February 2014
Journal Entry #1
One of the claims that George Orwell
makes in his article What Is Science?
is that “scientific education ought to mean the implanting of a rational,
skeptical, experimental habit of mind. It ought to mean acquiring a method – a method that can be used on
any problem that one meets – and not simply piling up a lot of facts.” In my
opinion, Orwell is completely correct about his stance on scientific education.
However, the issue is that when individuals learn about science in school, they
take away the idea that they can master the scientific subjects by memorizing
facts. Therefore, instead of sparking creativity and critical thinking, the
teaching of science reinforces the importance of memorization.
At a college level, a student begins
to learn that the field of science is not about recalling countless facts at
all. It is actually about relating facts, experiments, theories, and the works
of previous scientists to the modern world in order to gain knowledge about the
world we live in. As Orwell states, science is truly about developing a way to
come up to solutions for problems that actually arise in the real world and
scientists should be rational human beings. Having the ability to make rational
decisions is key, but George Orwell argues that scientists do not always think
as rationally as they should. For example, the creation of the atomic bomb
highlights the “dark side” of science because it shows that scientific research
can create very deadly weapons. A
major issue is that simply studying science is not enough to learn how to use
scientific for the right reasons. Perhaps, those scientists who designed the
atomic bomb for the purpose of harming others should have taken a few Philosophy
courses throughout their academic careers. This shows that sometimes scientists
focus too much on achieving the latest technological advances and not enough on
the effects that their studies would have on society. I feel that in order to
deem scientists as the most intelligent people on Earth, they must be
multi-faceted and educated in more than just the field of science. Scientists
and researchers should also be humanitarians that aspire to solve society’s
biggest problems, such as poverty, obesity, world hunger, global warming, etc.
Ultimately, I still have a lot of
respect for accomplished scientists who have made discoveries that allow us to
live as comfortably as we do today. However, I have just as much respect for
those who are revolutionary novelists and reputable politicians. In my opinion,
recalling scientific facts word for word do not signify intellect. We should
strive to enrich our minds with new ideas and methods rather than memorizing
facts that have already been proven in order to build on what we know. Reading What Is Science? by George Orwell
provoked me to think about what the word “science” actually means and why it is
a great field to pursue.
No comments:
Post a Comment