Wednesday, April 30, 2014

Journal Entry #4

Zumana Miyfa
ENG 21003 C
Professor Nargiza Matyakubova
15 March 2014
Journal Entry #4
Aylmer’s Real Motives
            The protagonist, Aylmer, from the short story The Birthmark by Nathaniel Hawthorne (1843) was a self-proclaimed “man of science.” However, after he married his wife, Georgiana, he realized that the crimson hand-shaped birthmark on her face continued to remind him of imperfection. Therefore, he conducted experiments on plants in order to devise an elixir that would remove the dreaded mark from her cheek. Aylmer’s underlying motives for removing the birthmark stemmed from his desire to gain spiritual power over human beings and to perfect one of nature’s creations.
            First off, Aylmer wanted to remove the birthmark from his wife’s face because he saw the crimson mark on her pale face as a “symbol of his wife’s liability to sin, sorrow, decay, and death” (p. 2). By these words, he meant that Georgiana’s birthmark constantly reminded him that she was a mortal human who would die one day just like everyone else. Therefore, by the end of the story, Aylmer concocted an elixir that was supposed to remove the mark from her face and allow her to live forever. If the elixir worked, it would have been his greatest scientific accomplishment because he would have done the work of God by perfecting one of God’s creations and determining how long that creation could survive.
            It also became evident that Aylmer wished to possess the powers of God when Georgiana asked her husband to remove that mark for both of them to be at peace, and he responded by saying, “Noblest, dearest, tenderest wife … doubt not my power. I have already given this matter the deepest thought – thought which might almost have enlightened me to create a being less perfect than yourself” (p. 3). This quote showed that Aylmer believed that his scientific abilities
gave him great power that humans should not doubt just as they would not doubt God’s powers. He also mentioned how one of his ultimate goals was “to create a being,” and he felt that he was enlightened enough to be worthy of such spiritual power. Although his desire to be God was obvious from the reading, it was not obvious that Aylmer would have only considered himself to be a successful scientist if he could reach perfection in flawed beings.   
            This idea of attaining perfection came to Aylmer’s mind from the books he read about naturalists who “imagined themselves to have acquired from the investigation of Nature a power above Nature, and from physics a sway over the spiritual world” (p. 7). Since he read so much about other individuals who defined scientific achievement as acquiring “a power above Nature” and gaining control over creating a human, Aylmer measured his success as a scientist through achieving perfection and immortality. In fact, he called his own book of experiments “a sorcerer’s book,” which means that he saw himself as a supernatural being and he wanted to be as impressive as God. However, Aylmer learned his lesson in the end when his elixir killed his wife, but he did achieve the power of perfecting God’s creation during the few minutes before Georgiana’s death when the red birthmark faded away.   


No comments:

Post a Comment